Guide
Section 18: the cap that turns a schedule total into a real number
Updated
A costed schedule tells you what the works would cost. Section 18(1) decides what the landlord can actually recover, and the two are frequently very different.
Request fee proposals Two minutes of questions; dilapidations surveyors covering the building send fee proposals directly. Free, no obligation.
What the section says
Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 covers repairing covenants during a lease and at its end. Damages for breach shall in no case exceed the amount (if any) by which the value of the reversion in the premises is diminished owing to the breach.
It also provides that no damage shall be recovered for a terminal repairing breach in one case. That is where, at or shortly after the tenancy ends, the premises would be pulled down, or such structural alterations made as would render the repairs valueless. Their state of repair does not matter (legislation.gov.uk).
The two limbs, in practice
- First limb: the cap
- Damages cannot exceed the fall in the value of the landlord's reversion caused by the breaches. Where the works would cost more than they add back to value, the value figure governs.
- Second limb: the bar
- Where it is shown the premises would be demolished or structurally altered such that the repairs would be valueless, damages for the terminal repairing breach are not recoverable at all. Landlord intentions at and shortly after termination therefore matter enormously.
The section 18 valuation: how the cap is evidenced
The cap is a valuation question, not a building question. It is usually evidenced by a diminution valuation: the reversion valued in its actual condition against its value in the condition the covenants required. That is a separate instruction from a schedule, often given by a valuer rather than the building surveyor who wrote it.
The dilapidations protocol expects the landlord to quantify loss by a formal diminution valuation, an account of actual expenditure, or both. A formal diminution valuation is required unless, in all the circumstances, it would be reasonable not to provide one.
Things that commonly reduce a claim
- The landlord's own works. If a refurbishment or reconfiguration would have removed the item anyway, its cost may be superseded.
- Redevelopment. Where demolition or structural alteration is shown, the second limb of section 18(1) can extinguish the terminal repairing claim.
- A schedule of condition annexed to the lease, limiting the standard the tenant ever had to reach.
- Betterment, where the schedule specifies replacement or upgrade beyond what the covenant requires.
- Market evidence. Where premises of this type let readily in the condition they are in, the diminution may be small even if the schedule is long.
None of this is legal advice, and section 18(1) has been the subject of a great deal of case law that a summary cannot capture. It is, however, the reason a schedule total should never be treated as a liability figure by either side.